Summary

  • Teams perform best when they include diverse ways of thinking, not just diverse demographics.
  • Cognitive diversity – differences in how people think, approach problems, and generate ideas – can be a key driver of team success.
  • Research shows that age, gender, or ethnicity alone do not predict team performance, but cognitive diversity does.
  • Teams with varied thinking styles are more adaptable, innovative, and effective in complex or uncertain situations.
  • Belbin Team Roles provide a practical framework for identifying and leveraging cognitive diversity within teams.

What is cognitive diversity?

While visible forms of diversity – such as age, gender, and ethnicity – are often the focus, there is a less obvious yet highly influential type: cognitive diversity.

This refers to the inclusion of individuals who think, approach problems, and generate ideas in different ways. Research shows that teams with high cognitive diversity often outperform those where thinking patterns are similar.

The importance of cognitive diversity

A pivotal study by Alison Reynolds and David Lewis followed more than 100 teams over 12 years as they worked on a strategic execution exercise.

The researchers found that team success was not significantly linked to age, gender, or ethnicity. However, teams exhibiting high cognitive diversity consistently performed better – particularly in complex or uncertain situations.

Cognitively diverse teams are better able to:

  • Apply existing knowledge effectively
  • Seek out new information proactively
  • Integrate specialised expertise with broader perspectives
  • Adapt to changing circumstances with innovative solutions

Our research and insights straight to your inbox

Join over 25,000 people who receive our research and insights once a week. Unsubscribe any time.

Why cognitive diversity is often overlooked

Despite its importance, cognitive diversity is frequently ignored because:

  • It’s invisible – unlike demographic diversity, cognitive differences are not immediately apparent.
  • Recruitment biases – organisations may favour candidates who mirror the existing team’s thinking style, inadvertently reducing diversity.
  • Comfort with homogeneity – teams often tend towards consensus and familiarity, which can suppress innovative ideas.

How to foster cognitive diversity

To build a team with strong cognitive diversity:

  • Embrace varied thinking styles – encourage team members to share alternative approaches and solutions.
  • Value different perspectives – seek input from individuals with diverse backgrounds and expertise.
  • Promote psychological safety – create an environment where team members feel safe to voice dissenting opinions without fear of repercussions.
I8 Report Page Featurette 70

How can Belbin facilitate cognitive diversity?

Belbin Team Roles provide a practical way to map and harness cognitive diversity within teams.

Each role represents a different approach to thinking and problem-solving, from the analytical Monitor Evaluator to the creative Plant, the practical Implementer, and the relationship-focused Teamworker.

By identifying which roles are present – and which may be underrepresented – teams can:

  • Balance decision-making styles to avoid blind spots
  • Combine complementary strengths for complex challenges
  • Encourage collaboration and innovative thinking
  • Ensure tasks align with individuals’ natural contributions

Using Belbin in this way turns cognitive diversity from an abstract concept into a tangible, actionable strategy for improving team performance.

Request a Demo

Let's explore how Belbin can help your teams work better together. Fill in your details and we'll arrange an online meeting to show you around the Belbin platform.